Romeo's New York Pizza

Overview

When you're craving a delicious slice of pizza in Johns Creek, Georgia, look no further than Romeo's New York Pizza. Located at 9700 Medlock Bridge Rd, this pizzeria brings a slice of New York to the heart of Georgia, offering both locals and visitors a taste of authentic, mouthwatering pizza that transports you straight to the bustling streets of Manhattan.

The first thing that stands out about Romeo's New York Pizza is its dedication to using only the freshest ingredients. Each pizza is made with high-quality mozzarella, tangy tomato sauce, and a hand-tossed crust that’s baked to perfection. Whether you prefer a classic cheese pizza or something a little more adventurous, Romeo’s offers a range of toppings, from pepperoni and sausage to fresh vegetables and even unique options like feta and sun-dried tomatoes. Each slice is packed with flavor, ensuring a satisfying meal no matter your tastes.

What sets this pizzeria apart is the pizza's size and texture. The thin crust is crispy yet soft, offering the perfect balance that makes each bite a delight. It’s not overly thick but still substantial enough to hold generous toppings. And if you're a fan of the foldable New York-style pizza, Romeo’s nails it every time, giving you that iconic experience with every bite.

If pizza isn’t your thing, don’t worry-Romeo’s New York Pizza also offers a variety of other dishes to satisfy your appetite. Their pasta options are equally delicious, with creamy Alfredo and tangy marinara sauces perfectly complementing tender noodles. For those looking to try something light, the fresh salads are made with crisp greens and a variety of toppings. And don’t forget the garlic knots-small, fluffy, and infused with garlic butter, they’re the perfect appetizer to start your meal.

The atmosphere at Romeo’s is warm and inviting, perfect for a casual night out with friends or a cozy dinner with family. The staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring that every customer feels welcome and well taken care of. Whether you choose to dine in or take your meal to go, the service is consistently top-notch, with orders prepared quickly without compromising on quality.

For those in the area looking to try Romeo’s New York Pizza for the first time, it’s worth mentioning that the restaurant is known for its generous portion sizes. A single pizza can easily serve two or more people, making it an ideal choice for sharing. And with a menu full of options, there’s something for everyone to enjoy. Plus, their convenient location means it’s easily accessible to residents of Johns Creek, Alpharetta, and beyond.

Customer reviews consistently praise the pizzeria for its authentic New York flavor and friendly service. Many visitors rave about the pizza’s quality, mentioning that it's hard to find pizza in Georgia that comes close to the real New York experience. Some even go as far as to say Romeo’s is the best pizza in the area, with no other pizzeria quite matching the taste and texture of a true New York-style pie.

The restaurant has built a strong reputation over the years, with locals returning again and again for the delicious pizza and comfortable dining experience. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite on your lunch break or sitting down for a family dinner, Romeo’s New York Pizza offers a reliable option that never disappoints.

With its commitment to authentic ingredients, delicious recipes, and a welcoming atmosphere, Romeo's New York Pizza has earned its place as a staple in the Johns Creek dining scene. Whether you’re a long-time local or a visitor passing through, make sure to stop by for a slice or two-you won’t regret it.

Good to know

Service options

âś“ Outdoor seating âś“ No-contact delivery âś“ Delivery âś“ Takeaway âś“ Dine-in

Highlights

âś“ Fast service

Popular for

âś“ Lunch âś“ Dinner âś“ Solo dining

Accessibility

âś“ Wheelchair-accessible car park âś“ Wheelchair-accessible entrance âś“ Wheelchair-accessible seating âś“ Wheelchair-accessible toilet

Offerings

âś“ Alcohol âś“ Beer âś“ Comfort food âś“ Quick bite âś“ Vegetarian options

Dining options

âś“ Lunch âś“ Dinner âś“ Dessert âś“ Seating

Amenities

âś“ Toilet

Atmosphere

âś“ Casual âś“ Trendy

Crowd

âś“ Groups âś“ University students

Planning

âś“ Accepts reservations

Payments

âś“ Credit cards âś“ Debit cards âś“ NFC mobile payments

Children

âś“ Good for kids âś“ High chairs

Parking

âś“ Free of charge street parking âś“ Free parking lot âś“ Parking

Pets

âś“ Dogs allowed outside

Photos

Location

Reviews

- No ratings yet 564 reviews
Amazing 390
Great 92
Okay 30
Not Great 23
Terrible 50
Tripradar

Stumbled in here after catching a movie next door, and honestly—don’t compare it to NY/NJ pizza, because… c’mon, that’s not fair. But for Georgia? Pretty solid! The veggie slice surprised me in the best way, and my friend demolished the wings. Bonus points for being open late when the cravings hit. Will definitely be back!

Sylvia Reyna

I enjoyed my visit, having recently come back from a trip to NY I was on the hunt for a good place for NY style pizza. I was in the area and tried them out. I had an issue ordering online but they corrected it so I was very happy with that. The pizza was delicious, I enjoyed the environment when I went. I’m about an hr drive but I’d definitely visit again.

Gavin Bigelow

I've been eating here for years now. Always a reliable slice before catching a movie. Stopped by for a whole pie tonight to bring home and was so impressed by how quickly they got out my order and how good it was I had to write a review. The staff was incredibly kind, the pizza came out quick and piping hot so we weren't left with a cold pizza after driving home, and the food was as good as ever. Tonight's pizza was fantastic. Cheese, sauce, and toppings were all in perfect ratios and the crust had a perfect crunch and soft fluffiness. Overall, we love Romeo's and will be back again soon!

Bryan Kang

Hidden gem next to the regal movie theater. Friendly staff, quick service, and the food is great! Meat lover pizza had a lot of meats & cheese, and best part is that it is not salty like other NY pizza places. Must try!!

Benjamin H.

Super fast and friendly service! I’ve been here twice, and the pizza has always been delicious. My favorite is the Supreme Specialty. They’re happy to accommodate your preferences and make the pizza just the way you like it. Always a great spot for some late-night pizza.

Yajur Gopinath

The atmosphere was awesome with the music and decor inside. The Mac and cheese jalapeno poppers and boneless wings were great. The margarita pizza and the supreme pizza were decent.

Write a review